So as I state on my “Why Blog?” page, practically everyone I know or ever come in contact with is very religiously and politically conservative. So how the hell did I get to be a dirty hippy liberal type? It’s hard to know how and why my brain waves evolved the way they did, as I can’t really step outside myself and observe how things progressed on the inside. But I’m certain it can be traced back to my education at the private, conservative, Southern Baptist-affiliated school known as Samford University. Samford is famous for producing graduates that end up as radical leftists. I kid.
I grew up in a very conservative Southern Baptist household, believing all the Baptist dogma: literal, inerrant Bible; wives submit to husbands; no sex before marriage; alcohol is sinful; Bill Clinton was the AntiChrist. Looking back on it, I’m shocked at how little I questioned. I just accepted absolute truth as dictated from the pulpit.
But a funny thing happened in college. I learned how to think. It’s strange and I’m ashamed to admit it, but before college I had virtually no critical thinking skills. That’s an indictment of my primary and secondary education and the way I was raised.
My college major was English, and I attempted but didn’t quite log enough hours for a minor in Religion. Of course at Samford, Religion = Christianity. My literature courses taught me how to critically analyze a text and see more going on than what seems obvious at first glance. But perhaps even more importantly, one of my religion courses did something I’m quite sure Samford’s Baptist forebears had never expected the school’s curriculum would do: it destroyed my belief in the “inerrancy” of the Bible. I can still remember almost the exact second it happened, in a course taught by this very brilliant man: http://www.gla.ac.uk/departments/theology/staff/paulholloway/ (who has obviously left Samford for a new gig). The details of how my belief crumbled are too complicated for this post, but in a nutshell it was a result of my exposure to objective, academic criticism of the Gospels. Which, BTW, is something very few Christians are ever exposed to.
So there I was, a senior in college, and the foundation of my entire belief system had been ripped out from under me. That was about 9 years ago. It’s been an especially difficult and complicated journey for me from a religious perspective. Via the internet I explored atheism at great length. I’m certain I now understand the atheist worldview better than 99.99% of Christians, and I flirted with taking that leap. But ultimately the sum of my life’s experiences kept me in the fold of Christianity, albeit with a drastically different perspective on it from the one I grew up with.
This had implications for my political belief system because I ended up questioning everything I’d ever been taught. This process was in its infancy in 2000. Not having progressed very far at the time, I must confess I voted for Bush that year. I had been deeply ingrained with the unspoken belief that Republicanism was ordained by God, and Democrats were the enemy. I was a Republican by birth, not by choice.
George W. put an end to that. Unlike my religious ephiphany on the nature of the Bible, I don’t remember the exact moment I realized I wasn’t a Republican; I spent a lot more time wrestling with spiritual issues than with political issues in the first half of this decade. But I understood that Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11 and recognized the insanity of that war from the beginning. My growing sense of horror at Bush’s incompetence and Cheney’s evil nature gradually led to a comprehension of the systemic problems in Republican governance: supply-side economics voodoo, deregulation of industries desperately needing regulation (Fannie and Freddie collapse, anyone?), insistence on legislating morality, support of corporate suppression of unionization efforts… the list of course goes on and on.
Essentially, the more educated I became, the more I questioned what I thought I once knew, the more I thought things through entirely for myself and stopped relying on others to explain “truth” to me, the further I drifted from my conservative roots. Note that this is about my personal journey. It is not my intent to make universal implications about conservatism here, although I’m certain I will in a future post…
July 16, 2008 at 5:44 pm
[...] 9 Numbers: My Journey From Conservative to Liberal Danner discusses his transformation [...]
July 23, 2008 at 10:31 pm
great story. thanks for sharing. here it is: i confess to voting for Bush in 04!
i’m a late bloomer, what can i say. but i have an interest in keeping my job so i’m somewhat quiet (at least on my blog) about the state of the union as i see it. instead i just talk about the kingdom of god which undercuts all the political stuff.
my conversion to inerrancy started at a state school in college (actually i was never schooled in the doctrine of inerrancy, partly b/c i was biblically illiterate). an English major at church (leave it to those guys) started questioning the differing accts of the gospels, the chronology, etc. this little rural church of christ lacked the tools to handle such a question (although there were like 3 PhD’s–go figure). later in graduate school i learned why.
the absurdity evangelicalism’s ability to hide higher criticism in the closet for more than a century is something that continues to baffle me.
we should talk more about this. i’d be interested to hear about some of the details of your journey. i’m a firm believer that the truth will set us free. peace.
July 24, 2008 at 7:38 am
Yeah, i’m sure in your line of work it’s prudent to be mostly publicly apolitical.
Definitely we can talk shop on this sometime.
August 11, 2008 at 8:27 pm
Hi, Danner. I’m Melissa. I enjoyed reading your story. Found your link at Left in Alabama.
August 29, 2008 at 10:18 am
I’m always fascinated by people’s stories about how they changed their beliefs. Did you ever read “Misquoting Jesus?” He’s got a similar story.
September 28, 2008 at 8:02 pm
As a native Alabamian, you give me great hope that more of us will recognize that “religion is for those who FEAR Hell… Spirituality is for those of us who have been THROUGH it.”
Yes, I’ve bookmarked your page.
October 24, 2008 at 4:13 pm
Thanks for the insight Danner.
I had a similar upbringing and the revelation that “destroyed my belief in the “inerrancy” of the Bible” happened at my church here in Birmingham, Pilgrim UCC…
We’re hosting a theology discussion at the Wine Loft Sunday November 16th at 4PM if you’re interested…
February 14, 2009 at 12:25 am
If someone could teach me I would like to construct a website. I liked your description of Bush and Cheney. The deregulation of the banking industry began with Ronald Reagan with old George Bush as VP. 3000 banks defaulted. The Silverodo Saving and Loan went under and Neil Bush walked away with millions, maybe billions. During the Reagan years George H. W. Bush. Donald Rumsfeld and Cheney sold nerve gas to Saddam Hussein. This was a violation of international law and the UN protested. The Reagan administration used their UN security vote to block any world action against the sale and use of the nerve gas. Suddam killed thousands of Iranians and Kurds and all the while Donald Rumsfeld was Saddam’s butt-buddy. During the Reagan administration Donald Rumsfeld also got a substance that had been banned by the FDA for 17 years approved and Monsato paid him somewhere between 4 and 12 million to do so. The substance is aspartame(nutraSweet, Equal) Clinton Handed George W. a big surplus. At the end of eight years our government(main street-you and me) face the largest deficit ever. With the deregulation of the financial industry the Bush Administration caused the fall of the world economies. Wall Street and the Bankers paid themselves huge bonuses while the Broker Houses were going BROKE because some politicians starting with the Reagan years thought we should get rid of the regulations that we put in place after the Stock Market cash in 1929. WE are bailing out the credit card companies and they are charging 24 to 64% on credit cards. WE are being ripped off by our politicians, the lobbyist and the banks. I could go on. Just let me end by saying that the FDA does neither, keep our food safe or our medicine safe. WE NEED A GREEN SUSTAINABLE ECONOMY.